After months of searching, the podcast finally tracks down "Willie Claws" to a mental health facility for the criminally insane in Trenton, NJ. The chance to speak with someone who many believe is possessed by an Evil Spirit is enticing, but securing an interview is nearly impossible due to confidentiality laws. In fact, the team's only chance may be to prove that Willie Claws is actually a man named William Haliday, who inexplicably massacred his wife and two children in Bridgeport, Connecticut in 1979 -- immediately after visiting the infamous Black Magic Colony built by the late Barbara Farmer, just before she herself was murdered by husband Charles in 1963.