Overthinking It Podcast

Support Overthinking It by becoming a member for $5/month!

The gang takes this show all the way to Broadway, with Matt Belinkie, Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matt Wrather celebrating Audra McDonald’s tour de force as Mama Rose with a look through the many adaptations and themes of Gypsy: A Musical Fable, by Arthur Laurents, Jule Style and Stephen Sondheim, based on the memoirs of Gypsy Rose Lee. Is it, as some critics claim, among the greatest American book musicals ever made? What would that even mean were it to be true? What does it have to do with King Lear? How does the fictionalization of its true story deal with reality vs. fantasy vs. the human condition? We discuss a paradox at the heart of many of the truly great theatrical parts: when they are played by the greatest actors in the greatest ways, do they ever really truly fall apart, or plunge from the heights into desperate ruin? What sort of dignity and sympathy does the ultimate fictionalized stage mom engender that may or may not be due to her historical antecedent? Who did it how, and how did it best? And where did Belinkie get a half-bottle of mead on a Tuesday? Everything’s comin’ up Otis!

Download (MP3)

Subscribe: iTunes Other Apps

Further Reading

• Audra McDonald in Gypsy: Now on Broadway (2025)


• The Bette Midler Gypsy TV Movie (1993), from Chicken Soup for the Soul TV


• The Imelda Staunton Gypsy Savoy Theatre Production, London (2016), from YouTube Movies & TV


• The Twisted Accounts Behind Gypsy: A Musical Fable, from Drama Dorks


• “‘Gypsy’ The Musical Is LGBT History?’” From the Philadelphia Gay News, September 2017


• The Female Broadway Belt Voice: The Singer’s Perspective, by Christianne Roll, Journal of Singing Volume 76, Number 2 pp 155-162, November/December 2019


• Paradise Lost, Book V, 859-869