Mugs of Mystery

On September 20, 2020 Alicia Navarro turned 16 years old. It is also the 1-year anniversary of her disappearance. If you have any information on Alicia’s whereabouts please call the Glendal Police Station at (632) 930-3000. Also, check out Jessica’s tiktok for more information @findalicianavarro as well as the Find Alicia facebook page: Finding Alicia - Home | Facebook SQUATCH

After a heated argument with her mother, Britanee Drexel goes out of town with friends to Mrytle Beach. This is the last time she was seen. The case would frustrate not only her family but law enforcement for years. For more information on human trafficking, visit https://polarisproject.org/ A child is buried alive, a suspicious beast torments a small town in the 50's, a Lizard Man

A young adventurous girl attends a party with multiple other people. She turns in early for the night and decides not to leave her tent when her friend asks her to take a ride home. She is never seen again. What happened to Maddy Scott? SQUATCHWATCH! Old Yellow Top, Canadian Lizard Man, Giant Wolves with big toes and more! https://www.patreon.com/pintsoftheroundtable

During a volatile divorce a little boy goes missing. Is this a case of child abduction, murder, or negligence? How does Law and Order SVU come in to play in the case. We discuss the disappearance of 2 year old Sky Metalwala. A hotel haunted by a little girl and a yapping dog. Monte tells us about Mel’s hole. And the every popular Squatch Watch! Also, we noticed a dead deer. https

A young woman with a troubled past and drug addiction goes missing after she is caught shop lifting in a local Georgia Wal-Mart. A failure to report her missing blocks any attempts of a successful investigation. Copious amounts of blood mysteriously show up at an elderly couples home. Is this something paranormal? Did it rain blood?  Or was a hoax played to con a couple of old

A young man at a loss of what to do about his future up and disappears from his family home in Washington. Several sightings of erratic driving and even stranger reports of running come next. What happened to Logan Drew Schiendelman? Where did he go? Were back in creepy, terrifying, bizarre Washington. This state seems to have no end to the creepiness. But what about the regular ol

January 12,2002 the Gill family traveled from the estate they worked on to nearby Viale. That was the last time the family had been seen. Is this a case of a family picking up and cutting ties with everyone and everything they know for a better life? Or did a strained relationship with their employer have a part to play? The devils cave, a headless priest, a moral-less woman and a

A nurse and mother of 3 goes missing one morning in September. Is this a case of a burnt out mother needing some time away, a successful suicide attempt or something more sinister? We discuss the disappearance of Tammy Kingery...and Casie almost dies A strange silver man perusing through catacombs under a university, lizard people, ghost treasures and more! https://www.patreon.com/

Con-artist or victim? Aging child star or murderer? Today we discuss the wild life and murder of Bonne Lee Bakley. A government science experiment gone wrong on a California dairy farm. The Billiwhack monster and more ghosts and ghouls.ghouls. https://www.patreon.com/pintsoftheroundtable

The day before Christmas Eve 1974, three friends had some last-minute Christmas shopping to do. Mary Rachel Trilca, 17, Lisa Renee Wilson, 14, and Julie Ann Moseley, 9, left for Seminary South Shopping Center with plans to be home by 4. They were never seen again. The case shocked Fort Worth residents and led to thousands of leads, dozens of searches, and hundreds of interviews. Te