Aug 12 2023 158 mins 3
In today's episode Gondal and I continued with our response to @Farid Responds.
Youtube version of this podcast: https://youtu.be/eEKf_s2Y8GY
Timestamps:
0:00 Introductions.
2:10 Debunking Lie #16 - Pretending to respond? Hiding slides.
9:30 The game of miracles - discrepancy between the Quran and the hadith on the frequency of miracles.
17:00 Sam Harris’s take on the game of miracles in Christianity.
21:03 The game of miracles (continued) - Farid believes in other miracles in the hadith, so why is he rejected this one?
29:36 Is Waqidi really unreliable?
35:01 Debunking lie #17 - The reference for Muhammad’s mom hallucinating, does it even exist?
41:52 Was it just a dream or did she see the light when she gave birth to Muhammad?
47:50 Debunking lie #18 – Farid does not understand hypnopompic seizures.
53:05 Debunking Lie #19 - Farid does not understand the epigastric rising aura.
57:06 Debunking Lie #20 - Muhammad’s chest splitting incidents. Editing a 10min discussion on chest splitting incidents into a 1min clip.
1:09:40 Debunking Lie #21 - Anas was born 36yrs after the first chest splitting incident so he cannot be an eyewitness!
1:17:50 Debunking Lie #22 - Chest splitting incidents supposedly occurred multiple times….why do we only have witnesses to just one incident?
1:22:35 Debunking Lie #23 - Heavy camel or fainting? The burden of revelation or dead weight effect.
1:32:20 Debunking Lie #24 - Farid Hid many instances of dead weight
1:37:30 Debunking Lie #25 - The dog VS Camel sniffing strawman. Epilepsy and the smell of fear.
1:44:50 Channel announcements
1:44:00 Can camels and untrained dogs detect seizures? Farid’s twisted logic.
1:54:30 Farid makes an apples-to-oranges comparison and his twisted logic.
2:03:15 Comments from the live section.
2:04:36 Farid’s malicious editing - Khasais al Kubra - Suyuti on severe trembling during ‘revelations’
2:12:45 The sound of bees is a more precise description of Muhammad’s seizures.
2:21:08 Farid cherry-picking hadith that support a particular narrative/ view.
2:23:10 Debunking Lie #26 - Trees speaking to Muhammad
2:29:01 How old was Ali when Muhammad started hearing voices?
2:33:55 Can you diagnose via witness testimony? Yes, but with many caveats.
2:35:40 Crazy descriptions of Muhammad’s seizures.
2:36:50 Final remarks.
Youtube version of this podcast: https://youtu.be/eEKf_s2Y8GY
Timestamps:
0:00 Introductions.
2:10 Debunking Lie #16 - Pretending to respond? Hiding slides.
9:30 The game of miracles - discrepancy between the Quran and the hadith on the frequency of miracles.
17:00 Sam Harris’s take on the game of miracles in Christianity.
21:03 The game of miracles (continued) - Farid believes in other miracles in the hadith, so why is he rejected this one?
29:36 Is Waqidi really unreliable?
35:01 Debunking lie #17 - The reference for Muhammad’s mom hallucinating, does it even exist?
41:52 Was it just a dream or did she see the light when she gave birth to Muhammad?
47:50 Debunking lie #18 – Farid does not understand hypnopompic seizures.
53:05 Debunking Lie #19 - Farid does not understand the epigastric rising aura.
57:06 Debunking Lie #20 - Muhammad’s chest splitting incidents. Editing a 10min discussion on chest splitting incidents into a 1min clip.
1:09:40 Debunking Lie #21 - Anas was born 36yrs after the first chest splitting incident so he cannot be an eyewitness!
1:17:50 Debunking Lie #22 - Chest splitting incidents supposedly occurred multiple times….why do we only have witnesses to just one incident?
1:22:35 Debunking Lie #23 - Heavy camel or fainting? The burden of revelation or dead weight effect.
1:32:20 Debunking Lie #24 - Farid Hid many instances of dead weight
1:37:30 Debunking Lie #25 - The dog VS Camel sniffing strawman. Epilepsy and the smell of fear.
1:44:50 Channel announcements
1:44:00 Can camels and untrained dogs detect seizures? Farid’s twisted logic.
1:54:30 Farid makes an apples-to-oranges comparison and his twisted logic.
2:03:15 Comments from the live section.
2:04:36 Farid’s malicious editing - Khasais al Kubra - Suyuti on severe trembling during ‘revelations’
2:12:45 The sound of bees is a more precise description of Muhammad’s seizures.
2:21:08 Farid cherry-picking hadith that support a particular narrative/ view.
2:23:10 Debunking Lie #26 - Trees speaking to Muhammad
2:29:01 How old was Ali when Muhammad started hearing voices?
2:33:55 Can you diagnose via witness testimony? Yes, but with many caveats.
2:35:40 Crazy descriptions of Muhammad’s seizures.
2:36:50 Final remarks.
