Mystery History Podcast

Listen now as Rachel and Alli discuss the most dramatic temper tantrum of all time. Marvin Heeymer felt like the local government and citizens of Granby, CO were putting him down. Not enjoying the fallout around him by the zoning commission and the refusal to make an agreement with a well to do family for sale of his property at an astronomical asking price, Marvin did what every n

Shawn Grate was a ladies man, with an extreme dark side. He was described as a nice guy with charming eyes who brutally murdered 5 women. This all culminated in 2016 when one of his victims was able to place a 911 call after Shawn passed out after brutally abusing her. The call lead police to a house of horrors! Listen in as we talk about Shawn's early life, his relationships,

Since the water level at Lake Mead in Nevada has dropped 170 feet, dead bodies are rising to the surface. So far, there have been 6 human remains found, with an unknown number still hiding below the surface. Listen now to Episode 174 - Lake Mead to hear the history of the lake and what we know about the bodies that have been found so far. Available now! Merch Store- Link in bio!! S

Mary Vincent's parents were going through a divorce and at the age of 15 she left home. Tired of living in cars, she decided to hitchhike her way to stay with her grandfather in Corona, CA. Unfortunately Mary never made it to Corona, Mary was picked up by 51 year old Larry Singleton. Larry seemed like a nice old man, and she had many miles left on her journey so she accepted a

This is episode surrounds itself around the poisoning murder of Mary Yoder in 2015, To this day, there is controversy surrounding the murder and conviction of Katie Conley. Listen as we dive into the events that took place and what we think happened in Episode 172 - The Murder of Mary Yoder. Shout out to Jamy for doing the episode notes and as always, the images for our episodes.

This story is WILD! David Nilsen was the Jeffrey Dahmer of London from 1978 to 1983 where he killed up to 17 young men. David stored bodies under the floorboards, kitchen sink, any other random places around the house. He strangled most of his victims, but some he nursed back to health and LET GO! Buckle up as Rachel and Alli discuss Episode 171 - Dennis Nilsen. Where to Find Us

In 2008, Julie Jensen was found dead in her bed by her husband Mark Jensen of an apparent suicide. Little did Mark know, Julie had given a letter to her neighbors telling them that if anything happened to her, to give the note to the police. In the letter, from beyond the grave, Julie said that if anything happened to her, it was at the hands of her husband Mark and that she would

An unidentified perpetrator, known as the Texarkana Phantom Killer committed several murders and assaults in Texarkana through the spring of 1946. Five people were killed, and three were wounded. Was the killer ever caught? Listen to episode 169 - The Texarkana Phantom Killer available now! Merch Store: https://www.teepublic.com/stores/mystery-history-podcast Patreon: https://w

Sydney Loofe failed to show up at work on November 16th, 2017 after going on a second date with a girl she met on Tinder named "Audrey". She had shared pictures of her date with a few friends who took to Tinder to locate the mysterious "Aubrey" after Sydney's disappearance...and guess what....they found "Aubrey". The police were able to track down

Gather round children and listen to the tale of The Cross Country Killer. Glen Rogers grew up right down the road from us in Hamilton, Ohio where through a hard upbringing and questionable morals he turned into a complete monster. He claimed to have killed 70 or more people all over the country. One of them could have even been Nicole Brown Simpson (OJ still sucks). With tons of