And a Rewatch Podcast

Apr 10 2025 200 ep. 85 mins 249
And a Rewatch Podcast artwork

"TV is comfort. It's a friend you've known so well and for so long, you just let it be with you..." So listen in each week as cohosts and special guests rewatch their favorite TV shows and discuss characters, ships, and pivotal moments. From reality competitions to sitcoms and everything in between, we love talking about TV almost as much as we love rewatching it!

  TV & Film  Arts
RSS feed Share
Copy RSS


Subscribe on Podcast Addict


Mythic Quest 4x10 Recap | "Heaven and Hell"

Apr 10 2025 118 mins  
It's our 200th episode! 🎉🎉🎉 There's really no way that we'd rather celebrate than by talking about the Mythic Quest season finale, "Heaven and Hell." Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) have a lot to say! (Jenn was an excellent secret-keeper. 🤭) They start by talking about the hilarious new role that Jo has been "demoted" to and what Brad's decision regarding Anna r

Mythic Quest 4x09 Recap | "Telephone"

Apr 02 2025 77 mins  
It's the penultimate episode of Mythic Quest this season, and that means a lot of characters are coming to terms with their next steps. There's a lot of FaceTime involved. It's time to discuss "Telephone"! Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) are back to discuss David's frazzled energy in this episode, the entire episode being an actual game of "telephone," a cliffhanger decisio

Mythic Quest 4x08 Recap | "Rebrand"

Mar 27 2025 109 mins  
Every season, Mythic Quest delivers us an excellent standalone episode, and this year we get to know more about Brendan in "Rebrand"! Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) are joined by their podcasting pal David (Gimmicks; Are You My Mother?; Fear Coded) to talk all about the theme of this episode, exploring what it means to grow up, parasocial relationships, talk about Ian's br

Mythic Quest 4x07 Recap | "The Room Where It Happens"

Mar 20 2025 101 mins  
On this week's Mythic Quest episode, Ian and Poppy's relationship finally fractures as David and Rachel appear before Congress. We're talking about "The Room Where It Happens"! Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) are joined by their lovely friends Sharai (A Nightmare on Fierce Street; Blerdy Massacre) and Emmy-nominated writer Alrinthea! They all discuss the Congressional heari

Mythic Quest 4x06 Recap | "The Fish and the Whale"

Mar 14 2025 93 mins  
This week on our Mythic Quest rewatch, it's time for a poker game that contains some pretty high stakes. Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) are joined by friends and former guests, Matt from Communiess (@communiess) and Elyse (@princessbilbo) to discuss "The Fish and the Whale"! The group talks about Brad trying to outsmart David in poker, what they thought of the 5-month time

Mythic Quest 4x05 Recap | "Second Skeleton"

Feb 28 2025 76 mins  
This week, Poppy deals with some news: she's pregnant! We're back to talk all about "Second Skeleton." Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) have so many thoughts about this hilarious, heartfelt episode. (We adore you, Ashly Burch!) They talk all about Poppy's fears of being a bad mom, how Ian tries to help, and what they think of Shannon being the person who ultimately gives Pop

Mythic Quest 4x04 Recap | "The Villain's Feast" (feat. Megan Ganz & Humphrey Ker)

Feb 20 2025 102 mins  
It's time for an Agatha Christie-style murder mystery party this week on Mythic Quest. Who's ready for "The Villain's Feast"? Jenn (@notajenny) and Chels (@chels725) have returned to talk about this absolute banger of an episode with the very funny and talented writers of it: Megan Ganz and Humphrey Ker! (Their adorable pug Hilda also makes an appearance in this episode. Go follow

Reality TV & Soaps Rewatch | Lucky, Get Behind Me

Feb 17 2025 101 mins  
While Paige (@thoughtsbypaige) is sick, Chels (@Chels725), Jesse (@speakupjesse), and Eoin (@EoinDaily) return to talk all about their favorite reality shows and soaps! The gang covers the first design challenge of the season and wonders why, after 17 seasons, some queens still don't take a sewing class. Tensions are high as some queens tattle on others for not using the provided m

Mythic Quest 4x03 Recap | "Breakthrough"

Feb 14 2025 76 mins  
Who's ready for a Warrior Within day? That's what some of the Mythic Quest crew is up to this week, and we're back to talk all about it! Jenn (@notajenny.bsky.social) and Chels (@chels725.bsky.social) are joined by their talented podcaster and writer friend Sharai (@sharai.bsky.social) to discuss a hilarious A-story with Ian, David, and Jo (as well as talk a lot about why Jo is the

New Girl 2x13 Recap | "A Father's Love"

Feb 07 2025 87 mins  
Welcome back to Apartment 4D, everyone! It's a new year, and Jenn (@notajenny.bsky.social) and Jaime (@jaimepoland.bsky.social) have returned to bring you more New Girl coverage in 2025. As we head into the final half of season 2, it's time to talk about "A Father's Love." They unpack the debut appearance of Walt Miller, Nick's complex relationship with his dad, Jess' desire to hel