Crime In The Coconut

Jul 25 2022 46 ep. 31 mins 41

Crime In The Coconut Podcast artwork

Hello! If you've stumbled on to our podcast then there is a chance you love true crime, mysteries, paranormal, morbid, or unexplainable things. Good news: SO DO WE! Join us each week for a new topic shared by either Amanda or Morgan on true crime, paranormal, folk lore, conspiracy theories and the like.

Copy RSS

Subscribe on Podcast Addict

Vampire Boyfriend, Richardson Family Murder

Jul 25 2022 21 mins

This week Morgan covers the gruesome tale of a romantic fantasy between an adult and child goes over the deep-end when a young girl is convinced that killing her whole family is in order for a toxic, manipulative love to exist. How does one continue life after something like that? Join us this week and give your opinion on most forms of social media at Crime in the Coconut.

Jeffrey Lundgren and The Kirtland Cult

Jul 17 2022 28 mins

This week Amanda covers another local Ohio story. Following Jeffrey Lundgren, a self-proclaimed prophet that unfortunately leads misguided members to murder a compliant and devoted family of five.

Cold Mysterious Car Fire Case

Jul 10 2022 23 mins

This week, Morgan covers the unsolved case of Leslie Barker, a school teacher. Found inside her car that was ignited with a mysterious substance; go over some ideas and theories this week with us and special guest, Jeremiah, an intern from Kent, Ohio.

The Hello Kitty Murder

Jul 03 2022 27 mins

Thanks for joining back after last time! Today Amanda covers the gruesome torture Fan Man-yee endured after her kidnapping for an entire month before her horrible demise. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter for updates on when new episodes are going to be released!

Christine and Lea Papin

Apr 03 2022 14 mins

For our season finale, Morgan wraps us up with a short and (maybe?) sweet episode covering the Papin sisters. Were these sisters justified in their murders? Or is it just a little too weird for that?

The Murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart

Mar 27 2022 19 mins

This Sunday, Morgan covers a nightmare that no teenage girl should ever have to experience. Cassie Jo Stoddart's killers made it a goal to make their evening exactly as if it were out of a horror movie. Join us this week at 1pm on most major platforms as we cover this weeks unfortunate circumstance.

Freddie and Truus Oversteegen

Mar 06 2022 13 mins

Morgan and Amanda cover an unlike any other sisterly bond this week in a short light-hearted episode, accopanied by a few glasses of wine. Join us this Sunday at 1p (est)!

William Bonin, Part 2

Feb 27 2022 30 mins

This week, Morgan covers the second part of her horrific story: William Bonin, a.k.a. The Free Way Killer... Not to mention his accomplices. Their means of torture and murder are covered in this second part episode of Morgans previous podcast entry. Amanda and Morgan converse over the judicial systems laws giving mercy onto those who do not deserve it.

Rodney Alcala, The Dating Game Killer

Feb 20 2022 25 mins

This week join Amanda and Morgan, as they cover their accidental duplicate story; The Dating Game Killer. Active between the years of 1968 and 1979, Rodney Alcala's death toll reached unknown numbers. Morgan and Amanda can agree that this fiend's end was sweeter than what he deserved. Join us and send us your thoughts on most major platforms and our email.

William Bonin, The Freeway Killer

Feb 13 2022 32 mins

This Sunday another new episode of Crime in the Coconut will flow into your head holes...preferably your ears. Morgan covers William Bonin (a.k.a. The Freeway Killer). A gruesome tale of the child torture/murdering type. We hope you can join us!