Everything Scary

Dec 09 2024 133 ep. 55 mins 76
Everything Scary Podcast artwork

Everything Scary is a podcast that delves into all things spine-chilling. While it primarily focuses on true crime, it also covers anything else that falls under the umbrella of fear.  For those listeners who HATE banter, this may not be the pod for you. We try to dial it back, since it does not appeal to everyone. But, it does still get away from us sometimes.

The hosts approach these serious topics with a balance of levity, ensuring it’s never at the expense of the victims. If you enjoy true crime and appreciate a touch of humor, you’ll likely find Everything Scary intriguing. You can listen to it on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Additionally, they have an Instagram account called Everything Scary Pod where you can connect with them. If you’re interested in bonus content and exclusive episodes, they also offer a Patreon. Enjoy exploring the eerie world of Everything Scary!

  True Crime  Comedy  History
RSS feed Share
Copy RSS


Subscribe on Podcast Addict


Shafia Family Murders

Dec 09 2024 43 mins  
Send us a textOn June 30th of 2009, a discovery was made of in Kingston, Ontario, Canada.A vehicle submerged in Kingston Mills Lock, inside was the bodies of 19 year old Zainab, 17 year old Sahar, and 13 year old Geeti, with them was their fathers first wife, 52 year old Rona. It seemed all to have been a horrific accident. That was until, authorities were made aware, that the brot

Oscar Pistoris- Patreon Episode

Dec 03 2024 81 mins  
Send us a textOscar Pistorius was a legend. Having had both of his legs removed below the knee, at the age of only 11 months old due to a congenital illness that he had been born with, Oscar was able to compete in both the Paralympics as well as the Olympic Games. He was a hero in his home country, South Africa. When Oscar met model Reeva Steenkamp, the two fell hard for one anothe

SURPRISE Episode- Craigslist Killer: Philip Markoff

Dec 01 2024 103 mins  
Send us a textSurprise!,We have recognized, that recently we have been taking the easy route, and just re-recording episodes from the beginning of the pod, when Matt was not yet apart of ES. But, here is a brand spanking new episode, unscheduled.:) With the holidays, and just general everyday life, we have both been busy as F. We, are looking to re record all of the past episodes,

Balloonfest of 1986-Re-done with Matt

Nov 25 2024 49 mins  
Send us a textBack in 1986, Cleveland was going through it! unemployment rates were well above the country average, They would be known as 'The Mistake on the lake'That was until United Way had a super, fantastic idea! They would release...... 2 million balloons into the sky!!! What could go wrong?! They would do this, and it would gain them a spot in Guinness book of records, and

Travis the Chimp- Redone with Matt

Nov 18 2024 95 mins  
Send us a textI am sure we all know about this case by now. Travis the chimpanzee raised by Sandy Harold, suddenly gets spooked and proceeds to viciously attack her friend Charla Nash. What was the build up? do chimps make good domesticated pets? Here is our take on it. I originally did this case with my sister, when I first started the pod in 2022. But, now we can get Matts take o

Wade Wilson Part 2

Nov 11 2024 51 mins  
Send us a textIn part 2 of out coverage of Wade Wilson, we will go over the day of the crimes; October 7th 2019, his arrest, his trial, and the strange, strange women who claim to love this man.Wade gained notoriety in 2024, when he went on trial for his 2019 crimes. Women all over the internet found him incredibly handsome, for some bizarre reason, that I cannot for the life of me

Wade Wilson Part 1

Nov 04 2024 70 mins  
Send us a textWade Wilson, became quite the headline, in 2024, when he went on trial for the brutal murders of 2 women; Kristine Melton (35), and Diane Ruiz (43)Wade had only been out of jail for 5 days, when he decided to have a few drinks, do a few drugs, and then murder these two innocent victims, in the morning hours of October 7th 2019, for no other reason, than that they were

The Scream Murder (The murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart)

Oct 28 2024 60 mins  
Send us a textAs per Matt's request! This was one, that Matt listened to Hayley and I cover, before he was ever apart of Everything Scary. And, he wanted to rerecord it, and release it, as close to Halloween as possible.This case, is hard. two idiot, teenage boys, who considered themselves to be 'film experts' had a desire to become "infamous serial killers" . and they chose someon

Daniel LaPlante- redone with Matt

Oct 21 2024 43 mins  
Send us a textIn one of the craziest true crime stories that I have heard, the story of Daniel Danny LaPlante reads like a fictional horror story. When I first started the podcast in 2022, I knew this had to be one of the first cases I told, and it was.But now, i wanted to go back and tell this case to Matt and hear his thoughts on one of the wildest cases. and, that's what we did.

Nick Carter Part 2

Oct 14 2024 112 mins  
Send us a textIn this part of our coverage of Nick Carter, and the allegations made against him, we will go through the tragic deaths of Leslie, Robert, Aaron and BJ. We will also go through, what each of the alleged victims, claim happened to them, and how Nick and his team responded. Please see Part one for all of the sources used for these episodes.Please listen with care, as th