Five Star Match Game

Feb 25 2025 42 ep. 43 mins 105
Five Star Match Game Podcast artwork

On the Five Star Match Game, host Joe Gagne leads two contestants through a grueling game of wrestling trivia, with each episode centered around a common theme!
This podcast is a member of the Voices of Wrestling Podcast Network.
Learn more about the Voices of Wrestling Podcast Network at voicesofwrestling.com.

  Sports
RSS feed Share
Copy RSS


Subscribe on Podcast Addict


5 Star Match Game #42: AEW redux

Feb 25 2025 41 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns, and we're so excited we just can't hide it, because we are returning to the land of All Elite Wrestling! Matt Feuerstein (@mayorMGF), Erin Quinn (MsErinQuinn), and Andy Napier (@napdaddy33) battle through a collision of Elite trivia! Who goes all out and builds their trivia dynasty? Tune in and find out!Support this podcast at — https://r

5 Star Match Game #41: 2024

Dec 30 2024 52 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns for our fourth annual year in review show, covering wresting events from around the world in the past 12 months. And we have a power panel as Alan Counihan, Mike Spears, and Case Lowe field questions about WWE, AEW, Japan, Mexico, and more! Questions are answered, grievances are aired, and a great time is had by all. Happy New Year!Support this podc

5 Star Match Game #40: SID

Oct 14 2024 50 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns as we pay tribute to the life and times of Sid Eudy. And there is no better collection of contestants than the crew of Center Stage Chronicles, as Rob Naylor (@NINaylor), Kris Zellner (@KrisZellner), and Charles (@pwoloss) handle trivia from all facets of Sid's nomadic career. No softball questions here! Listen now and find out who is the master

5 Star Match Game #39: Ring of Honor redux

Sep 16 2024 56 mins  
The Five Star Match Game is back as we return to Ring of Honor, focusing on the glory years of 2002-2008! And joining us on this journey is Jesse Collings (@jessecollings), Sean Sedor (@SASedor2994) and Robin Reid as they engage in their own Survival of the Fittest to see who reigns supreme! You'll be slapping the nearest barricade in excitement!Support this podcast at — http

5 Star Match Game #38: The Life & Times of Mick Foley

Jul 10 2024 41 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns as we pay tribute to the career of the hardcore legend himself, Mick Foley! We cover it all, from WCW to ECW to the WWF and all points in between, from deathmatch tournaments to classic promos. And we have a super panel of guests: returning favorites Joe Sposto (@NotJoeSposto), Rob Naylor (@NINaylor) and first time guest Charles (pwoloss)! A tremend

5 Star Match Game #37: 2000's Puro

May 06 2024 64 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns welcomes two first time guests, Mike Sempervive (@sempervive) and Dr. Keith Lipinski (@KeithLipinski) along with returning favorite Case Lowe (@_InYourCase) to cover a bevy of questions covering New Japan, All Japan, NOAH, and so much more (plus a little MMA)! Lots of great trivia and big laughs, this show is a can't miss!Support this podcast at

5 Star Match Game #36: Sting

Feb 27 2024 40 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns with a special episode paying tribute to the retiring legend himself, Sting! Andrew Rich (@AndrewTRich), Lee Malone (@WCWThunderPod) and Andrew Sinclair (@AMSinclair97) answer trivia about Sting spanning decades - this one goes back to UWF all the way to AEW with stops in WCW, TNA, and even Japan. A must listen show!Support this podcast at — https

5 Star Match Game #35: 2023

Dec 29 2023 52 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns with our annual year in review show, as Alan Counihan (@Alan4L), Mike Spears (@fujiiheya) & Case Lowe (@_InYourCase) return to field trivia from all spectrums of wrestling, including WWE, AEW, Japan, Lucha, and much much more. Grievances are aired, laughs are had, and the winner ends up really despondent. An incredible way to end your 2023!Suppo

5 Star Match Game #34: Ruthless Aggression!

Aug 15 2023 44 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns with a special show dedicated to the Ruthless Aggression era of the WWE! The Boys of Summer themselves, Justin Shapiro (@jmshapyro), Matt Feuerstein (@mayorMGF) and Trevor Dame (@TrevorDame) return to answer questions about an incredibly bonkers period in WWE history. Who wins the million dollar prize? Who has elevated liver enzymes? Who gets buried

5 Star Match Game #33: Bret "The Hitman" Hart

Jul 05 2023 45 mins  
The Five Star Match Game returns with a special show dedicated to Bret "The Hitman" Hart. Our power panel of Alan Counihan (Alan4L), Lee Malone (@WCWThunderPod), and Griffin Peltier (@Hollywd12) field a series of questions about Bret's career from Stampede to WCW. Who will be the best there is, the nest there was, and the best there ever will be (at trivia)? Who gets SC