Water fluoridation is regarded as one of the most significant public health advancements of the 20th century. Its implementation has had a profound impact on reducing tooth decay, particularly in children, by fortifying dental enamel against decay-causing acids. To fully understand its origins, it is necessary to explore the historical context in which fluoride was first identified as a beneficial agent for dental health. The journey begins in the early 20th century, when the mystery of mottled teeth in a small Colorado town led to groundbreaking discoveries about fluoride’s role in strengthening teeth. In the early 1900s, Dr. Frederick McKay, a dentist in Colorado Springs, Colorado, noticed that many of his patients had an unusual condition affecting their teeth. Known as “Colorado brown stain,” this condition caused noticeable discoloration or mottling on the enamel. Despite its unsightly appearance, McKay observed that these patients exhibited remarkably low rates of tooth decay. Intrigued by this paradox, McKay partnered with fellow researchers, including Dr. G.V. Black, to investigate the phenomenon further.