Lady, You’re Scaring Us

Mar 04 2025 111 ep. 35 mins 6
Lady, You’re Scaring Us Podcast artwork

Just two ladies introducing their friends to the world of true crime and weird stuff. New episodes weekly!

  True Crime  Society & Culture  Comedy
RSS feed Share
Copy RSS


Subscribe on Podcast Addict


Ladies Unscripted: Love On The Run

Mar 04 2025 68 mins  
Join us as we (along with a few listeners!) discuss the Netflix documentary Jailbreak: Love On The Run. It’s a wild ride of crime, forbidden love and phone sex! Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Sylvia Likens

Feb 11 2025 64 mins  
Teenager Sylvia Likens died at the hands of Gertrude Baniszewski, a woman who was supposed to take care of her. But Gertrude didn't commit her crimes alone...she had a little help from the neighborhood kids. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Ladies Unscripted: Natalia Grace

Jan 28 2025 53 mins  
Just us yapping about The Curious Case of Natalia Grace. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Bonus Content: Hear Us Out…

Jan 21 2025 16 mins  
No story. Nothing to do with True Crime. Just us doing a “Hear Me Out” cake. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Jerry Brudos

Jan 14 2025 53 mins  
What won't a man do for a pair of high heeled shoes?? Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Cheri "Sugar Babe" Brooks

Dec 10 2024 46 mins  
The murder of Vera Jo Reigle. Vera was a sweet girl mentally disabled girl who ended up basically trapped in a terrible family. The matriarch, Sugar Babe, was compared to Charles Manson due to her ability to get others to do her dirty work. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Herb Baumeister

Oct 24 2024 60 mins  
Our listener Lauren tells us a story about a real creep! Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Christine Paolilla

Oct 10 2024 31 mins  
Mariesa tells us about the Clear Lake Murders. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Angela Stoldt

Sep 24 2024 37 mins  
Was it self-defense or cold-blooded murder that she committed before boiling a man's head? You can decide. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus

Lou Castro

Aug 27 2024 38 mins  
A little story about a little cult run by Lou Castro...or was it Joe Venagas?...or Daniel Perez? We'll just call him the Angel of Death. Send us a message!! follow us on instagram @lady_yourescaringus