The Case Within

Nov 17 2023 9 ep. 19
The Case Within Podcast artwork

When a new lead prompts a fresh look at a cold case, Special Agent Nicole Baumer is tasked with finding out what really happened to sixteen year old Erin Michaels. But as parallels surface between her past and Erin’s, Nicole must finally confront her own trauma in order to save her.

  Fiction  True Crime
RSS feed Share
Copy RSS


Subscribe on Podcast Addict


Episode Eight: Repercussions

Nov 17 2023 28 mins  
Charles is taken into custody, but without a witness willing to speak or a confession from Charles himself, they may not be able to convict him, and now another child's life hangs in the balance. Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content: @thecasewithin Credits: The Case Within stars Jillian Clare as Nicole,

Episode Seven: Nuclear Family

Nov 10 2023 22 mins  
Nicole rushes to find evidence that proves Charles McDonaugh was involved in the killing of Erin and a final glimpse into the past with the events that led to the death. Content warnings: threats of sexual assault, wife abuse, violence and racially sensitive issues. Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content:

Episode Six: Bloodlines

Nov 03 2023 21 mins  
Nicole stakes out McDonaugh's new house, but things go sideways when her psychologically unstable state gets the best of her. Content warnings: issues related to racial oppression by law enforcement, unwanted sexual advances. Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content: @thecasewithin Credits: The Case Within s

Episode Five: Year One

Oct 27 2023 23 mins  
In the past, Charles condemns Erin to a year of confinement, and in the present Nicole struggles to deal with the emotions working on Erin’s case have brought up for her. Content warnings: depictions of confinement, violence, deprivation and restraints. Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content: @thecasewi

Episode Four: Little Boxes

Oct 20 2023 29 mins  
Special Agent Baumer retraces the steps of the original agent on the case and, in doing so, makes a disturbing discovery about Erin’s possible fate. Content warnings: suggestions of confinement and violence. Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content: @thecasewithin Credits: The Case Within stars Jillian Cl

Episode Three: Old Wounds

Oct 13 2023 23 mins  
In a Bureau mandated therapy session, Nicole reluctantly opens up about her own trauma in an attempt to forestall being relieved of duty. Content warnings: depictions of sexual assault, physical violence, restraint and abduction Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content: @thecasewithin Credits: The Case With

Episode Two: Erin

Oct 06 2023 22 mins  
Ten years earlier, teenaged Erin Michaels is hitchhiking to San Diego when she meets a pregnant couple whose intentions are not what they seem. Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content: @thecasewithin Credits: The Case Within stars Jillian Clare as Nicole, Jillian Shea Spaeder as Erin, Eric Martsolf as Char

Episode One: Nicole

Sep 28 2023 24 mins  
New evidence prompts Rookie FBI agent Nicole Baumer to reopen the cold case of a missing girl with disturbing parallels to her own past. Tune in every Friday to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content: @thecasewithin Credits: The Case Within stars Jillian Clare as Nicole, Jillian Shea Spaeder as Erin, Eric Martsolf as Charles, Mar

The Case Within Trailer

Sep 21 2023 2 mins  
Tune in every Friday starting September 29th to hear the story unfold. Follow the show on Instagram for exclusive behind the scenes content! @thecasewithin The Case Within stars Jillian Clare as Nicole, Jillian Shea Spaeder as Erin, Eric Martsolf as Charles, Martha Madison as Jennifer, Jonathan Robbins as the Narrator, Abhi Sinha as Suresh, and A Martinez as Director Mendez. With P