True Terror on Tap

Mar 06 2025 26 ep. 52 mins 6
True Terror on Tap Podcast artwork

Welcome to True Terror on Tap, the ultimate podcast for fans of the eerie and the macabre. Join us as we delve into the chilling realms of true crime, horror, creepypasta, lore, myth, and the paranormal. Each episode, we serve up spine-tingling tales and bone-chilling stories, all while enjoying a few beers to keep things lively.

Whether you’re here for the darkest true crime cases, the most terrifying horror stories, or the spookiest paranormal encounters, True Terror on Tap has something for every fan of the frightful. Grab a drink, sit back, and let us take you on a journey through the shadows, where the only thing scarier than the stories we tell might be the next round we order. Cheers to the terror!

New show from The Behill Network!

  True Crime  Comedy  Society & Culture
RSS feed Share
Copy RSS


Subscribe on Podcast Addict


Inside the Life of Israel Keyes Part 2

Mar 06 2025 48 mins  
Send us a text Israel Keyes was unlike any serial killer we’ve ever seen—methodical, patient, and terrifyingly precise. In Part 2 of our deep dive, we pick up where we left off: Vermont, June 2011. Keyes had just arrived, retrieving a kill kit he had buried a year earlier, and searching for his next victims. What followed was an execution of a double murder that would later bec

Inside the Life of Israel Keyes Part 1

Feb 27 2025 60 mins  
Send us a text In the first episode of our deep dive into the life and crimes of Israel Keyes, we trace his journey from an isolated childhood in rural Washington to his time in the U.S. Army, uncovering the early signs of a predator in the making. Raised in a strict and extremist household, Keyes developed a fascination with violence, control, and meticulous planning—skills that

Listener Tales – Encounters with the Unknown

Feb 20 2025 54 mins  
Send us a text Real stories. Real terror. No urban legends—just firsthand accounts from True Terror on Tap listeners who experienced the unexplained. In this chilling episode, we dive into encounters that defy logic: • The Padre Hotel Haunting – A guest knowingly checks into one of Bakersfield’s most haunted hotels, only to experience the infamous shadow figure firsthand. �

Escaping the Highway

Feb 13 2025 59 mins  
Send us a text "On a cold February night in 2004, Maura Murray crashed her car on a dark New Hampshire road. She was seen standing beside it, refusing help. Just seven minutes later, she was gone—without a trace." "Nearly a decade later, in 2013, Bryce Laspisa was driving home to his parents in California. But something wasn’t right. His behavior became erratic, his route made

The Smiley Face Murders: Coincidence or Conspiracy?

Feb 06 2025 51 mins  
Send us a text "It starts the same way every time. A young man, out drinking with friends, laughing, celebrating. It’s late, maybe 1 AM, maybe 2. The bar’s closing. His friends turn their backs for just a second, maybe to order an Uber, maybe to use the bathroom. When they turn back—he’s gone.” “At first, no one panics. He probably just walked home. But then, hours pass

Robert the Doll: The Cursed Toy

Jan 29 2025 59 mins  
Send us a text It's strange how we often ignore the mundane. A doll, sitting innocently on a shelf, a child's plaything... it's hardly the sort of thing you'd expect to shatter your world. But that's what makes this story so terrifying. The most unsettling things often hide in plain sight, disguised by innocence. In Key West, Florida, there's a doll named Robert. He's not just any

The Dyatlov Pass Incident part 2

Jan 22 2025 59 mins  
Send us a text When we left off, search and rescue teams had uncovered the Dyatlov group’s abandoned tent—slashed open from the inside and eerily undisturbed except for the ominous tracks leading downhill into the forest. What they found next was even more horrifying: bodies scattered in various states of undress, some with injuries so severe they defied explanation, others app

The Dyatlov Pass Incident part 1

Jan 09 2025 40 mins  
Send us a text “The Ural Mountains, February 1959. Nine experienced hikers from the Ural Polytechnical Institute set out on what should have been a challenging but ordinary trek. Days later, their campsite was discovered in ruins. Their tent had been slashed open from the inside. Their bodies were scattered across the mountainside, some barefoot in the snow, others with bizarre i

New Year’s Nightmare: The Disappearance of Sheryl Sheppard

Dec 30 2024 56 mins  
Send us a text A new year—a fresh start, a clean slate. It’s a time of celebration, reflection, and resolutions. For many of us, it’s a night to dress up, go out, and toast to brighter days ahead. There’s something magical about New Year’s Eve: the countdown, the fireworks, the feeling that anything is possible. It’s a chance to live in the moment. The thrill of the nig

Unmasking the Dark Spirit of Christmas

Dec 19 2024 46 mins  
Send us a text Dive into the chilling world of Krampus, the half-goat, half-demon enforcer of holiday morality. In this episode of True Terror on Tap, we journey through the centuries-old folklore of the Alpine region to uncover the pagan roots, symbolic elements, and terrifying traditions surrounding this dark counterpart to Saint Nicholas. From the eerie rituals of Krampusnacht t