My Cryptid's Keeper

Mar 04 2025 37 ep. 48 mins 7
My Cryptid's Keeper Podcast artwork

Two Sister's revisit their childhood obsession with cryptozoology in this podcast devoted to monsters, cryptids, and local legends.

  Comedy
RSS feed Share
Copy RSS


Subscribe on Podcast Addict


The New Hampshire Wood Devils

Mar 04 2025 51 mins  
Is that a dvil in your pocket or are you happy to see me (sorry, sorry, sorry). This week Maddie and Mackenzie travel to New Hampshire to discuss the mysterious wood devils. Listen to hear the sisters debate if these elusive cryptids are a kind of bigfoot or just really lost moose. Stick around to the end to hear Maddie fighting for her life in a game of two truths and a lie. Al

The Jersey Devil

Feb 18 2025 42 mins  
He can be your angle or yuor devil... This week Maddie and Mackenzie dive into the garden state king: The Jersey Devil. The sisters explore his 18th century origins, his goofy ass appearance, and how Ben Franklin himself may be responsible for his creation... Listen to the end to hear which cryptids would have the most iconic beef with each other.

The Maryland Goatman

Feb 03 2025 48 mins  
50% goat, 50% man, 100% totally real and not made up at all guys I promise! This week Maddie and Mackenzie head to Maryland to discuss the Maryland Goatman. The sisters discuss his childfree lifestyle, his similarities to another axe wielding cryptid in the area, and his mad scientist origins. Stick around to the end to weigh in on the debate: which half animal/half human combo w

Icelandic Sea Monsters

Jan 20 2025 63 mins  
Join Maddie and Mackenzie as they traverse to the fjords of Iceland to discuss the party of sea monsters to be found there! The sisters cover the antics of the absolutely adorable fjorulalli, the sinster merman hafmaður, ther Icelandic loch ness monster the faxaskrímsli, and a the thick queen known as the skeljaskrímsli. Stick around to the end to weigh in on which boy band arch

The Enfield Horror

Jan 06 2025 45 mins  
This week Maddie and Mackenzie learn of a monster from the cryptid haven of Illinois: The Enfield Horror! Listen as the sister recount this creature's short but sweet reign of terror that horrified this small town in the 1970s. Stick around to the end to hear a new, ground-breaking, theory about a previous cryptid case...

The Yeti

Dec 23 2024 50 mins  
In honor of the winter season, this week the sister's trek the Himalayas to cover the abominable snowman himself - The Yeti! Listen as Maddie and Mackenzie navigate one of the most bizarre stories they've covered yet. Get ready for a tale of mountaineers, Alexander the Great, Buddhism, a new understanding of DNA analysis, and - wierdly - West Virginia. Stick around till the end to

The Bunyip

Dec 09 2024 43 mins  
This week the sister's head down under to cover their first ever Australian cryptid: The Bunyip! Listen as they discuss his terrifying appetite, his possible prehistoric origins, and as they try and fail to do a good Australian accent.

The Ghost Brides of North America

Nov 18 2024 49 mins  
This week Maddie and Mackenzie delve into the world of supernatural and discuss local legends of ghost brides from across the USA. Listen to hear the tales of love gone wrong, sisterly betrayal, and a weird amount of hotels. Stick arond till the end to hear Mackenzie's first hand account of a ghostly encounter and a DIY exorcism in the sisters' childhood home.

The Third Eye Man

Nov 04 2024 42 mins  
This week Maddie & Mackenzie delve into the terrifying tale of South Carolina's premier creepy tunnel dweller: The Third Eye Man. Listen to the sisters discuss his underground dwelling, his sightings on the University of South Carolina campus, and his possible ghostly origins. Stick around to the end to hear them discuss which college tropes each of the cryptids would fall into AN

Urban Legends of Halloween

Oct 21 2024 43 mins  
Trick or Treat! As a spooky season special Maddie and Mackenzie are covering the true tales behind Halloween traditions. Remember to check your candy and keep those Jack-O-Lanterns lit until after the clock strikes 12! Happy Halloween!